PC Gaming … still d0med!!!1one
Did’ya hear? Microsoft released Halo and Shadowrun recently and required gamers to get their new Vista OS to play them and pay $50 a year for Shadowrun to be able to play against XBOX360 gamers! And what about other new games from third-party publishers ? They aren’t following suit: they are allowing gamers to use Windows XP or Vista. The injustice of it all! How can they just turn their back on … oh, wait, that is a good thing.
And then there is the upcoming Gears of War … aside from the injustice of having to wait 12 months for it to arrive on the PC, we find out that it will feature content and downloads that will be UNAVAILABLE for XBOX360 gamers. Can you believe THAT!?! Not only do we have to wait but … we … um …
There are a couple of interesting games coming to the PC this week – and of course, both are also coming to the XBOX360. You know what that means, right – yep, we get some ‘XDroppings’ … let’s take a look:
If you are like me then you are highly anticipating the release of Bioshock this week, the so-called ‘spiritual successor’ to the amazing System Shock games. My initial thoughts on this were highly skeptical – I took a ride on THAT particular train last year with Dark Messiah of Might & Magic, thank you very much. But it turns out from every early indication that this one is going to be pretty good. So if, like me, you are a PC gamer, then you have also been sitting on the sidelines while your XBOX360-owning friends have had a demo of the game for over a week. The PC demo is coming, so they say – but that only makes me think of a line from Real Genius “Coming?!?! It isn’t even breathing hard!” It has been announced, denied, confirmed, unconfirmed, released, unreleased … and so on. Of course there is an excuse ready for the separate demos – seems there is a different development house doing the PC interface than the one doing the XBOX360 interface. Uh huh, we know what that means. So now there are reviews starting to trickle in and some feedback from the developers. Yeah, I know – get your outrage and PR filters ready! So the developers are saying that because the Australian studio doing the PC version had more time that it will be what they call ‘more polished’ and ‘a better version’. And the early reviews are calling the PC version ‘better than the XBOX360 version’ and commenting that the game ‘controls better’ and ‘looks better’, and that it is beyond just the typical ‘mouse & keyboard advantage’. Yeah, we know how all of that works with ports … and … um .. what did they say … PC version better … controls better … HEY?!?!?!
OK, so .. so maybe with Bioshock we won’t see things like the ini files of Deus Ex Invisible War with lines saying ‘set this to 0 if not on the XBOX’ that aren’t set to 0 … or have fonts that take up half the screen like in Oblivion. But that is probably just because Bioshock is revolutionary and astoundingly good, and one of those ‘once in a lifetime’ deals. I’m sure that won’t be true with Two Worlds. Let’s see – coming to PC and XBOX360, open world game in the spirit of the Gothic series and recent Elder Scrolls games like Morrowind and Oblivion. Ah, yes, an Oblivion clone … this should be good. So what can we learn from looking at the development history – the game was released for PC in Europe a few months ago, and has since seen five patches that have focused on tweaking gameplay and balance and taking care of bugs and other issues. All of this was done so that the XBOX release would reflect final quality. Yeah, we knew that was coming. But it was all done on the PC so that gamers in Europe note that every aspect of the game has improved significantly from beginning as a fairly problematic game to being a very polished and much better balanced experience. So we have a game that has been tested and tested and quickly patched and is now running quite nice and polished on the PC. Well, at least the initial version was pretty broken so we can still claim PC gamers got screwed, right? No? We can’t … hmmm …
So we’ve got a couple of decent games this week, but what else is there to show on the PC? I mean, no one develops for the platform anymore! Let me think of stuff I’ve played that was new and pretty decent on the PC recently – there was the latest Civilization IV expansion that was excellent, the independent Nethergate Ressurection from Spiderweb Software, another independent Gods: Land of Infinity, the awesome adventure series Sam & Max Season One, more cool adventure games Dead Reefs and Secrets of Atlantis, not to mention the really cool, S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl from earlier this year. And looking forward there are games like the Neverwinter Nights 2 expansion, The Witcher, independent RPG’s like Eschalon Book 1, Depths of Peril, Legend: Hand of God, Hard to Be a God, Not the Time for Dragons and so on. DOSBox continues to make better and better versions bringing more compatibility to old games.
What the heck is going on here – it seems almost like PC gaming ISN’T doomed, after all? Sure it isn’t holding the heyday position it had when Baldur’s Gate 2 was released seven years ago in 2000, but heck, there wasn’t even an XBOX at that point! Speaking of which, the thing that really started me on this tear was a thread in a forum somewhere ranting about the XBOX360 users were getting screwed because they weren’t getting the Gears of War downloads and a … heated … debate about whose platform was getting screwed the worst ensued and it all sounded like little kids whining to their parents. Some sounded like the youngest complaining that he got the least freedom; others like the oldest complaining that the baby was spoiled; still others sound like the middle child complaining that they get screwed from both sides.
Gaming is alive and doing very well – genres are being split apart and ideas are being ripped from all sides to make cool new games where they have never existed before. One of my two favorite RPG’s this year has a combat system based on match-three puzzles, the other is a tough-as-nails mega-old-school dungeon crawl where you have to draw your own dungeon … and both are on handhelds! I have been enjoying games on my three gaming systems – PC, DS and PSP – across all genres and non-genres, and seeing loads of great games released for other systems as well. Yet there are plenty of people who will tell you that the PC is doomed … or the PSP or the PS3 or that the Wii will be dead by summer or fall … or whenever Nintendo can get them to stay on the shelf …
Don’t listen to them. You are a gamer to have fun, not be miserable. I remember letting myself get very upset when Steve Jobs took over Apple and killed the Newton, then I realized that it was still the best PDA available and it wasn’t until a couple of years later when the synchronization software and my corporate email software stopped talking to each other that I ended up putting it aside. There are loads of fans still having tons of gaming fun on the Dreamcast; my kids get tons of use from their GameCube library despite the fact that it ‘lost’ the last generation; and the fact that the PSP has already ‘lost’ this generation has never stopped me from enjoying some of the really excellent games on the platform. So take heart – if you are a PC gamer you can rest assured that PC gaming will continue to live on. It has always been the most expensive way to game, and always will be – but it is far from ‘d0med’!
August 20th, 2007 at 12:59 pm
I can’t wait for Bioshock on the 360 tomorrow I…
oh wait.
Nah, I love the PC and owe so much to PC gaming. It pains me that a lot of the complaints you say above are true. It used to be that we PC fans would feel sorry for people waiting for Half-Life on the console, or Doom. I even remember back in the day laughing at the NES version of the Ultima games …
I am so old.
But now the fear is the other way around. After seeing Madden 2007 for PC last year, well, it made me really sad. The PC could have supported the 360 version of Madden but as it stood it barely compared well to the console 06 version. I wonder if that’s changed today?
Irrational – excuse me, 2K Boston or whatever – is a company well run and well rooted in PC gaming. I’m willing to bet the PC version of Bioshock is going to be awesome. I’m not willing to put money on it (I really am buying the 360 version) but I’m willing to make the bet.
Let us know Mike, will ya?
August 20th, 2007 at 2:14 pm
Madden is an interesting thing and I think it represents the worst view of the gaming industry as a whole. I mean – it took 3 iterations of ‘next gen’ to get it feature complete to the ‘last gen’ ?!?! What is up with that? I don’t know how the PC version is this year, but like you I found the PC version of ’07 to be a joke – and that was compared to the PS version I played!
But what I am saying here is that things seem to be stabilizing, and that it isn’t so simple to just say “PC Gaming is Doomed’ (or d0med as ‘they’ like to say). From everything I’ve heard, Irrational really did things right, had a big team working on ‘core code’ and separate teams in ‘Boston’ and ‘Australia’ working on the interfaces for the X360 and PC respectively. Such that the overall game is superlative, but for those with the rigs to play both the PC is the better version. That is a pretty rare thing. Same deal with Two Worlds.
So maybe in 2004 or 2005 PC gaming was doomed, but things have hit a pretty decent point – people are making some money, making some games, and a nice independent scent has cropped up. Cool. Keep on gaming!
August 20th, 2007 at 2:19 pm
Until I can write papers and do my taxes on a console, I will continue to own a PC, meaning I will continue play games on it. Sure, the PC is also a utility machine, but it attracts a demographic that likes games and has the technical expertise to make them. This is why PC games will never go away. To be fair, I think that PCs and consoles will eventually converge. Of course, consumers will need something more compelling than Vista and an a 3-year-old Halo title to make that happen.
August 20th, 2007 at 3:43 pm
Well, given that most of the missing Madden features over the last few iterations weren’t things I personally missed (I played 2-player, side-by-side, with a friend, pretty much exclusively – so all I really care about is physics, graphics, fidelity, and playability) I forgive almost everything that was missing. Probably has a lot to do with resources… EA naturally has to spend a lot more time, money, and genius (in a limited span of time) on the vast PS2 audience.
It’s a fair point though, but Madden360 has been worth my while every year – and I’d wager most fans don’t mind. Does that make it right? No, of course not.
To build on Alan’s comment – it’ll take more than Shadowrun too.
August 20th, 2007 at 10:59 pm
I went ahead and picked up the PC version of Madden 08. I’m not sure what features are supposed to be the “new” ones this year; but, there certainly is a lot of play with. It recognized my new Xbox 360 controller* immediately and has a configuration all set for it. The graphics are a bit off here and there; but, then, my PC is showing its age. (2.0GHz Athlon, 512MB Radeon X800 AGP, 1GB RAM) Framerates are smooth at 1440×900 with medium-high textures & details. I’m loving on the Superstar mode right now; unfortunately, my QB got drafted by the Cowboys. (Blech…on the plus side, I get to throw to Glenn & Owens, which is padding my stats quite nicely, thank you.)
August 20th, 2007 at 11:00 pm
:sigh: Forgot the *Not really an Xbox 360 controller; but a knockoff from Logitech with fans inside to keep my hands cool.
August 26th, 2007 at 10:02 am
I had a 360 for a day and well I’m coming back home to the pc – warts and all. IT’s mainly a controller issue for me for the games I play on the pc. m/k is just so second nature and inherently faster and more precise. Also for those games I play on the pc I tend to like to sit right in front of the screen.
For arcadey stuff a Wii is fine.
I could get a 360 too, but there’s alot of overlap there with the pc and I’d rather spend the extra money on keeping up the pc as best as possible. Plus it’s not like I have the time to play all the pc/Wii games I want anyway.